Untargeted metabolomics for inborn errors of metabolism: Development and evaluation of a sustainable reference material for correcting inter-batch variability

The Clinical Chemistry Journal Club allows readers to discuss key articles by using focused slides as teaching tools. Each month Clinical Chemistry posts the original article and slides online, and they are then distributed to individuals and university Journal Clubs.

Original Article: https://doi.org/10.1093/clinchem/hvae141

Slides: Download ppt

Abstract

Background

Untargeted metabolomics has shown promise in expanding screening and diagnostic capabilities for inborn errors of metabolism (IEMs). However, inter-batch variability remains a major barrier to its implementation in the clinical laboratory, despite attempts to address this through normalization techniques. We have developed a sustainable, matrix-matched reference material (RM) using the iterative batch averaging method (IBAT) to correct inter-batch variability in liquid chromatography-high-resolution mass spectrometry-based untargeted metabolomics for IEM screening.

Methods

The RM was created using pooled batches of remnant plasma specimens. The batch size, number of batch iterations per RM, and stability compared to a conventional pool of specimens were determined. The effectiveness of the RM for correcting inter-batch variability in routine screening was evaluated using plasma collected from a cohort of phenylketonuria (PKU) patients.

Results

The RM exhibited lower metabolite variability between iterations over time compared to metabolites from individual batches or individual specimens used for its creation. In addition, the mean variation across amino acid (n = 19) concentrations over 12 weeks was lower for the RM (CV_total = 8.8%; range 4.7%–25.3%) compared to the specimen pool (CV_total = 24.6%; range 9.0%–108.3%). When utilized in IEM screening, RM normalization minimized unwanted inter-batch variation and enabled the correct classification of 30 PKU patients analyzed 1 month apart from 146 non-PKU controls.

Conclusions

Our RM minimizes inter-batch variability in untargeted metabolomics and demonstrated its potential for routine IEM screening in a cohort of PKU patients. It provides a practical and sustainable solution for data normalization in untargeted metabolomics for clinical laboratories.